Patchwriting and plagiarism charges

In some cases Zakaria blends sentences from multiple reports, as in example 7, where he borrows from both The New Yorker and Al Jazeera.

Treat students, faculty and staff according to UMUC standards and policies, administered in an impartial manner. Whether or not the journalist meant to plagiarize is a question best reserved for determining the severity of the crime, not for establishing whether it happened.

A reduction in the grade on the work in question. Whether paraphrasing or summarizing, credit is always given to the author. The social context of critical care clinical judgment.

If the President denies the appeal, copies of this letter will be kept in the central records file in the Office of the Provost and Chief Academic Officer.

Across multiple reports, the authors at Our Bad Media have cited at least three dozen instances in which the CNN host and Washington Post columnist appeared to have lifted passages from various publications and websites for unattributed reuse in his books and magazine articles and on his television program.

Successful vs. unsuccessful paraphrases

Is some of the language in the article unoriginal? This can occur when a reporter sets out to "match" a story by interviewing the same sources without acknowledging the news was first reported elsewhere.

If the writer wishes to use some phrasing from the source text, that portion of the text has to be quoted that is, reproduced in an exact manner within quotation marks.

But journalism is also often about telling a story, conducting an investigation, or explaining something complicated. Because now, if you look at all the work that populates the marketplace of ideas, it is written by reporters, bloggers, aggregators, commentators, curmudgeons and both professional and amateur opiners.

And a gaggle of self-appointed fact-checkers may be plugging sentence after sentence into Google for any traces of dishonesty. Upon request, the student may see the information submitted against him or her relating to the allegation.

Did the author fail to set off unoriginal language or ideas with quotation marks? The Provost will respond, in writing, within 28 calendar days of the receipt of the petition. Their job is to give assigned patients all their nursing care. In the second, he lifts facts and language from a Economist article, also without attribution.

In order to avoid patchwriting, careful handling of sources is, of course, essential, as well as knowledge about how to paraphrase. But taken together, they show an undeniable pattern of behavior. Writing that brings new value to the audience, maybe even writing that merely attempts to bring new value to the audience, is likely to be intellectually honest.

Stealing the selection is stealing the intellectual work of that writer. Provost and Chief Academic Officer Subject: Note how the attempted paraphrase the patchwriting is too close to the source; instead of paraphrasing the source text, there are word-for-word substitutions of synonyms and identical sentence structures.

For effective communication, it is necessary to have a fairly accurate idea of what our listeners know or do not know that is pertinent to the communication. They came to the same conclusion I did: Click on the image below for a PDF you can cut out and keep nearby for the next time you come across suspicious copy.If you’re reading this, a journalist has been accused of what Poynter's Roy Peter Clark calls “the unoriginal sin": plagiarism.

Plagiarism is a serious charge. Academic Dishonesty and Plagiarism. Academic dishonesty is the failure to maintain academic integrity. UMUC defines acts of academic dishonesty (see section IV); ensures procedures for due process for students accused or suspected of acts of academic dishonesty on work performed within a course (see section V); and imposes appropriate sanctions.

According to the Free plagiarism book created by Unplag, "Patchwriting is cutting and pasting material without adding anything of the value to the content. A student may change a few sentences around and swap a few words to avoid plagiarism charges, but it's not their own thoughts, words, or conclusions".

Our Bad Media's latest report focuses on 12 instances of perceived plagiarism at CNN. Quoting, Paraphrasing, Summarizing & Patchwriting Quotations You copy a sentence directly from an article you found.

You cite the source, but you forget to use quotations marks = PLAGIARISM. Plagiarism is taking credit for someone’s intellectual work or ideas in assignments. It is an academically dishonest act.


This tutorial defines plagiarism and helps increase skills to recognize and avoid plagiarism.

Patchwriting and plagiarism charges
Rated 4/5 based on 18 review