It deprives us not only of what we value now and would have, given our current predilections, valued later, but also of what we would have come to value. The counterargument mentioned represents a misunderstanding in my thesis.
Importantly, he notes that this does not only apply to humans but rather to all species, or anything with a future of value for that matter. A famous unconscious violinist. Just because abortion is morally impermissible, it does not mean that society will deem you a bad person for getting an abortion under extreme circumstances.
Other Free Papers from this subject: Killing for the good of the person being killed. Euthanasia is a good killing. As I said, it is impossible to consider all scenarios and therefore we must establish general guidelines rather than an answer for every possible outcome.
It does not distinguish between beings with futures like ours and beings who have bleak horrible pain and unnecessary suffering filled futures.
In order for anyone to prevent a strong case for any argument, it is very important to address potential counterarguments. Thus, life support is provided to people in coma, mentally retarded and above of all to a living existence.
Any theory which cannot capture the wrongness of wanton infliction of pain on animals is incomplete. Unfortunately, this is true and for that reason it is impossible to address each and every possible scenario. Killing it wrong because it goes against our desire to continue to live.
At first thought, many people would deem the situation unfair and immediately request an abortion. Otherwise, abortion is immoral because you and I have the same valuable future that a fetus has the potential for. Embryo is mature zygotes; it is an organism in the earliest stage of human development.
By then he will have recovered from his ailment, and can safely be unplugged from you. In fact, if I were put into such a situation, I too would request to be unplugged from the violinist because I was unwillingly taken advantage of and do no want to have to deal with the issue.
In order to establish the conclusion that the vast majority of abortions are wrong, Marquis does not need to show that a necessary condition of the wrongness of killing some being is that it deprive it of the value of a future like ours.
Get Access Why abortion is morally wrong Essay Sample No matter how you slice it, abortion is morally wrong.
Marquis then connects this idea with abortion by saying that aborting a fetus is depriving a being of a valuable future. You are speaking on the very same grounds as to the reasons for explain why abortion is immoral.
Thomson presents a clear but unfortunate reality that society deals with much to often. I think that the most compelling counterargument is there simply cannot be one correct answer when it comes to abortion because there are so many variables that create unique circumstances. If P1 then killing a fetus is immoral P3: He has equalized them to plants and other mere metabolism consisting species, which cannot be victimized due to lack of activity or ability to think.
Essentially, Marquis offers one explanation as to why killing could be immoral while clarifying that it could be one of many reasons for killing to be immoral. This counterargument poses a very realistic concern but it is one I believe to be dismissible.Why abortion is morally wrong Essay Sample.
No matter how you slice it, abortion is morally wrong. Although that should not be misinterpreted for a pro-life stance on abortion because there are numerous circumstances that must be considered in each situation.
In Don Marquis’ article Why Abortion is Immoral, he makes the argument that.
The Abortion Debate: Are Abortions Immoral? Print Reference this. Disclaimer: In view of issues discussed in this essay, it is evidently clear that abortion is not any different from killing, a practice that deprives the victim of a future-like ours. Don Marquis- Why Abortion is Immoral; Don Marquis- Why Abortion is Immoral.
What is Marquis’ argument for the impermissibility of abortion? P1: It is immoral to kill a being like me. A Report On Architectural Determinism Anthropology Essay; Woning in Nederland.
Why Abortion Is Immoral: An Argumentative Analysis The argument on the immorality of abortion is a long standing philosophical discourse which opens itself to numerous discussions or even attacks.
Don Marquis' "Why Abortion is Immoral" In his essay "Why Abortion is Immoral," Don Marquis argues against the morality of abortion on the premise that the value of a fetus' future is so great that it is immoral to take that potential future away from it. Why Abortion is Immoral by Don Marquis is an essay that claims that abortion is morally wrong, and uses one argument in particular to explain why.
He argues that many of us would agree that it is wrong to kill a human, and if you believe that then you should also have that view on abortions. If you.Download